63 Comments

User's avatar
Mikehaymister's avatar

The only reason Russia has resorted to war was the refusal of the US to give up creating a platform in Ukraine for the future war and subterfuge against Russia.

Nakayama's avatar

The "West" has collectively removed God from the Altar, and put "science" and "logic" into that place. Then "science" and "logic" cannot be handled by the public, so they must be defined by experts. The experts are, more often than not, hired hands of certain "interest groups". Since we all spatialize our world differently, there is no universal values, not even universal "science" or "truth". I think, Mr. Crooke wanted to argue that there needs to be something universal, something that can be accepted or rejected by ordinary people by their intuition, without somebody specialized in interpreting "God's Wills" or the "meaning of science".

What Confucius had argued about (and must be many other Western philosophers, but I am ignorant) is that "human" must be the center of the "human world". To the minimal, respect for human lives, such as being willing to go through troubles to save lives, or the WW2 stories about soldiers who stopped shooting when both sides saw nuns leading disabled children walking across cities torn by the war, etc. Science and engineering must be centered on the long term benefit of the public, rather than the bank accounts of the capitalists. Capitalists deserve to have their property protected, but so do beggars to have something to eat. Then a compromise has to be found somewhere. If AI and robotics not only replace human employment, but also designed to kill humans, then something needs to be done to restrain such development. If unlimited human birth is harmful to humans in the long term, then something has to be done to allow people to slow down the birth rates, as now.

I cannot possibly share your religious belief or preference in clothing or marriage, and neither can you share mine. But in theory, we can all share a common belief, say, to save another human when we can, to push a person through legal proceedings rather than lynching, to share some wealth and food when times are bad, etc.. then there is a basis for the two or more sides to at least talk. However, if I believe people of your race are subhumans and need grass-mowing from time to time, then there is no road to peace.

61 more comments...

Ready for more?